Some people argue that multiculturalism defines Canada as a progressive country where newcomers can retain their cultural identities while participating in the wider society. Others argue that multiculturalism prevents newcomers from integrating with the existing population and prevents the formation of Canadian values and identity.
Write about a personal experience or an observation that illustrates the unifying or divisive aspects of multiculturalism.

by Nicco Bautista

Nicco Bautista
“A house divided cannot stand.”
The policy of multiculturalism at first glance appears to be unifying, yet it is innately divisive because it emphasizes what is different, rather than what are true Canadian values. By encouraging ethnic and cultural groups to perpetuate their distinctiveness, multiculturalism has created a disunity that can be understood in any language.
Much to the chagrin of idealists, the sad reality of multiculturalism is that it is based on inequality—essentially, having an accepted set of values surrounded by the customs of other cultures. Due to Canada’s overwhelming desire to be perceived as being politically correct, a great concern is the principle of cultural superiority. Presently, Canadian multiculturalism’s “ethnic integrity” is about preserving each tradition, belief, and value of every culture. Consequently, to try to prohibit or change certain cultural traditions is to discriminate, to act culturally superior, and to be perceived as being racist.
Canada, of course, can only have one policy, resulting in the approval of one culture’s values over another’s. Once this occurs, then the perception of cultural superiority arises, such as the failed attempt to legislate Islamic Sharia Law in Ontario. The result is cultural tension where people of differing cultures become more aware of their differences, and their inherent diversity becomes a source of bitter conflict and hatred.
By remaining exclusive, cultures also risk ghettoization. Locally, the overwhelming size of the Chinese community in Richmond is a glaring example of cultural division within the cosmopolitan region of the Lower Mainland.
The greatest example of the divisive nature of multiculturalism, however, can be seen in Quebec. Recently, I visited Gatineau, the little town that straddles the border of Ontario and Quebec, where it is taboo to speak English, regardless of the proximity to Canada’s capital, Ottawa. The residents’ determination to preserve the French culture is so strong in Quebec that it overtly repels all other influences. By separating themselves from the rest of Canada, Quebec has effectively created a nation within a nation, using its unique heritage and culture as barriers, shields to protect it from others’ attempts to pierce the soul of its distinct society. Is Canada willing to spawn such hostility? Consider the race riots that wrecked London and Paris. Is Montreal next? Ultimately, the divisive nature of multiculturalism may cause Canada to implode, beginning with the separation of Quebec.
The telling divisiveness of multiculturalism appeared on my recent trip sponsored by the Federal government to Ottawa, where the Caucasian guide of the House of Commons tour asked me: “Are you Chinese?”
“No,” I replied naively, “I am Canadian.”
He then proceeded to put me in my proper place, saying: “Oh! You mean Chinese-Canadian.”
After fifteen years in the country I consider home, I have come to realize that I do not belong – perhaps I never will. And despite my ethos and convictions, it will be nearly impossible to be a pure “Canadian.” From the tone of the man’s voice, it seemed presumptuous to describe myself simply as “Canadian” without any hyphenation. Former Prime Minister Diefenbaker saw multiculturalism as divisive for this very reason: it destroyed the essence of unhyphenated Canadianism. So long as Canada emphasizes difference, it will not allow for the full integration of immigrants into the Canadian mainstream.
Consequently, the divisive nature of Canada’s multicultural policy is appropriately referred to as a “cultural mosaic.” Like tiles in a mosaic, each culture is a part of the Canadian identity. The sad truth is that they are separated by the uncompromising cement of hyphenated Canadianism, destined never to touch each other and remaining forever disenfranchised from mainstream Canada. As the future of the nation hangs in the balance, Canada must not sacrifice its social cohesion at the altar of Multiculturalism. Despite Prime Minister Trudeau’s grandest visions in the Multiculturalism Act, Canada has yet to become a more unified society as multiculturalism is the antithesis to nationalism.

by Livia Poljak

Livia Poljak
I was at school. It was spring, the windows were opened and the air was fragrant with the flowering apple and almond trees.
The teacher was lecturing my class about my home country on the Balkans,
My heart was full of love, and my eyes were moist with tears of joy. As I went to wipe my eyes, I slowly realized that I had a dream. I looked around, and I quickly noticed that I was in my own room, in my city,
I was sitting in the living room, watching my favourite TV show. It was a hot, summery day. The sun was almost glaring down at me, and the sky was pale blue from the scorching heat. Yet out in the distance I noticed dark, purple-grey clouds roaming through the horizon. I could even hear a faint rumble of thunder. Suddenly the screen went black, and then a famous politician appeared. His face was serious and solemn. He started talking about the new laws of
My heart was full with happiness, but I felt a faint uneasiness too. I wanted to ask something when I slowly realized that I had a dream. I saw my piano, and with smile I noticed that I was in my own room, in my city
I was in the basement of my house. It was biting cold outside. The winter was showing its fierce power. The wind was howling, the snow was piling, and I heard the screeching of the frozen, bare branches of the trees. Then it started again. First I heard the thundering of the war planes, followed by the dreadful whistling sound, and then the deafening detonation of the bombs. I looked out the little window, and I could no longer see my neighbour’s house any more. For a moment it was dead silent and then I heard the screams of the wounded and the last sighs of the dying.
My heart was icy cold with fear, dread and sadness. Why the hatred, the rage, and the killing between the different Yugoslav nations, when the new laws were supposed to bring them even closer? Why the brothers’ war? I sat up with a jolt, and then I realized that I had a nightmare. My eyes glanced over my cherished history books, and merrily I noticed that I was in my own room, in my city,
It was spring again. The trees were blooming with unusual, unknown flowers. Everything was green, pink, yellow and bright around me. I was back at school. I had a social studies class, and the teacher was talking about my country,
Soon I realized that I had a dream. I was safe, happy, and carefree. I saw my Harry Potter poster on the wall, and I knew that I was in my own room, in my city,
Now I am not dreaming, and I don’t want to have nightmares any more. I am in a beautiful country called

by Samantha Ling

Samantha Ling
When my parents emigrated from their comfortable and familiar birthplace of Hong Kong to the strange and foreign country of
After five years, we grew weary of our surroundings and decided to move to
People are able to immigrate from different countries and still be able to expect that they will not lose their culture. They can adapt to the ways of our society without having to abandon their own traditions. All the distinct cultures make up what
Multiculturalism in
$100
by Jason Cheung

Jason Cheung
Multiculturalism is an aspect of life in which Canadians pride themselves in, by showing a wider range of acceptance than any other country. However, the gang-related violence and racist remarks beg the question of whether multiculturalism divides or unites. By drawing from my past experiences, I believe that although multiculturalism can be divisive when poor judgment is used, it does generally unify this great nation. I believe the main reason multiculturalism unites is that a balance is struck between one’s personal culture and other cultures. Secondly, the idea of multiculturalism is bred from a young age, as children accept it as their own beliefs. Lastly, unlike other less accepting countries,
Living in a multicultural society can be difficulty at times, as one may feel torn between his or her nationality and the Canadian culture. Local groups in
When a child in
Relative to other countries in this modern world of ours,
Multiculturalism in
by Kayla Hildebrand

Kayla Hildebrand
“You’re so white,” my friends casually jested. I laughed heartily at the comment, but later reflected upon what it truly meant. To be dubbed white seemed so boring and dry, bleached of all cultural flavor; a term to mean average, just another one of those American-like folk from the race of majority. I felt like one of millions of plain slices of white bread longing to be that unique loaf of multigrain rye, topped with something so rich as peanut butter and marmalade; I was a third generation Canadian who seemed to have lost all heritage and tradition. I had no culture to share with others, being so plain, so white.
I realized that as a young child; I yearned for culture and went out in search to find one for myself. So, rather inquisitive of others’ customs and heritage, I attempted to adopt their ways of life so that mine, too, could be enriched by the unity of such tradition.
My first phase began with an attempt at learning to speak and write Chinese. But, as my efforts concluded in vain, I turned to find a new outlet. I tried my hand at Indian culture, picking up the odd Punjabi phrase here and there and attending traditional parties to which I even wore authentic Indian dress. I was constantly badgering my closest Indian friends to teach me a new Punjabi phrase, so when she finally did, I practiced it to perfection. While dining at an Indian restaurant later, I proudly yelled the words to an unsuspecting friend. Little did I know, however, was that I had just bellowed some very vulgar obscenities for all the other guests to hear. After this failure, I was reluctant to move forward. Though, I continued to persevere and the last path of my voyage led me to attempt the resurrection of my German grandmother’s culture. This time I dug a little deeper, persisted further, and even learned to pray and recite poetry in her native tongue. Yet, having lived here for so long her German blood ran only faintly through her veins, driven merely by a weak cultural pulse; I had seemingly come to a dead end.
After relentlessly searching for a defining culture, I was no further than where I had begun, except now I was banned from one of our local Indian restaurants, too. I was desperate to adopt an identity to set me apart from society, to render me unique. For I knew, culture was strict and divisive; a person was either Chinese or Indian or German, it was not effective for one to be a combination. Of course, people of different races could correspond in everyday life, but in the big picture, they must be kept separate.
These divisive thoughts caused me to step back to reexamine my life, my thoughts, my feelings, and most of all, my lack of strong culture. Suddenly, I realized I was not missing a culture so much, but the right attitude towards it. I had been looking at this concept through a broken lens, focusing on the wrong aspects and values, seeing it as something to set one apart: a barrier. Yet, people’s cultures should really do the opposite: help to draw us together in unity, as in a country like
My childhood desires were piqued by these exciting cultures, as are we all attracted to the individuality of others because we respect their differences. Every culture combines to form a great mosaic held firmly together unifying the country. Because of this, I can enjoy a smorgasbord of roti and chai for breakfast, followed by a midday snack of Wiener Schnitzel, and Chow Mein for dinner. And, I as a Canadian, although considered ‘white’ and seemingly without a specific culture, can be seen as my own kind of mosaic, with the freedom to encompass and share in the experience of many different cultures. Paradoxical as it may seem, it is the multiculturalism and diversity in
by Dickson Ho

Dickson Ho
For years now, immigrants and their families have immigrated to
My family came to
I fail to see how multiculturalism prevents immigrants from integrating with the existing population. The existing population is filled with people who have lived in
The formation of Canadian values and identity is based on multiculturalism; hence, people of different cultures can live within this democratic society. If immigrants are deprived of this privilege,
by Morag Keegan-Henry

Morag Keegan-Henry
The first day of school. For me, that is. It was the middle of January, and I was just about to start grade four at a new school, after moving halfway across the province. My younger sister and I set off for the bus early. We sat side by side and whispered about what we’d do in class. You see, at our old school, all the primary grades were in the same class, then grades four to six, and then grades seven and eight. This was only my second year of school and so far I loved it. This was about to change.
My sister was put in a different wing of the school. I was hurried into a large classroom where a roomful of strangers glared at me menacingly. I smiled at everyone, sure of a friendly welcome, and sat where the teacher asked me to. By the end of the day, my smile had started to fade. My friendly advances had been rebuffed by everyone. When the teacher turned his back, whispers and giggles would start all over the room. At first I would giggle back, but gradually I realised they weren’t being friendly.
After school, my sister was crying as we walked home. Neither she nor I could figure out why everyone seemed to hate us. It wasn’t until the boy next door befriended us and explained the situation that we understood. This was a First Nations community. We didn’t belong. We weren’t especially rich, we didn’t look like them - in fact, my sister was the only blonde on the island. Another European was considered “in” because her family was extremely rich, and had lived there for generations. She was a year older than me, but she was far more sophisticated.
The only time those girls ever made me feel accepted was when they wanted to make fun of me later. For example, they were determined to give me a makeover. Why, I could not fathom. Eventually I gave in, hoping against hope that they would finally become my friends. At recess the next day, they brought their makeup. When they finished, they looked at me and all burst out laughing. I have never been so humiliated. I looked hilarious - and the worst part was, it didn’t come off until I got home! My parents got me to laugh at myself, and to see the funny side, but I still have nightmares about it.
What those girls did to me changed my veiwpoint on life, but the worst embarrassment I caused myself. A new student joined our class, with long dark hair, who was always smiling, named Sky. I tried to make friends with “her”. It turned out “she” was a boy! The entire class thought I had a crush on him. I had never heard the word “crush” before that.
I was lucky. After a year of this, my parents moved to a big city, where cultures mingled easily. No one teased me for my skin colour. People of all different origins were friends and comrades. In this city, multiculturalism is more about the number of excellent restaurants you can find than about any difference or separation.
I long ago forgave the children who tortured me so much. There were two reasons for this. Firstly, they never realised how much their bullying hurt me. I only cried in front of them once, and that was because someone hit me . They taught me a lot, about not trusting strangers, and about not expecting everyone to love you.
The other reason I forgave them was because I have to admit that they did have good reason to hate all Europeans. They had been treated as animals, in a manner that ripped their rights away, the ripples from which were still showing when I lived there in 2000. Their parents had been ripped from their homes as young children, and sent to a “residential” school where they were forcibly taught English and forced to forget their native languages and culture.
I recovered from my bad experiences. I understand now how awful it feels to bullied because of your skin colour or where you are from, things that you have no control over. I learned to accept people, not in spite of their differences, but because of them. That is the most important lesson I have learned in all my life, and I am grateful that I learned it so early.
by Raymond Kwok

Raymond Kwok
Through my eighteen years I have observed many things about the multiculturalism in
I am of Chinese Vietnamese descent and I went to a Chinese dominant elementary Catholic school. It was clear that the amount of students who were not of Chinese descent could be counted on ten fingers. Possibly our school was located in Chinatown where the Chinese population in
Entering high school I’ve encountered many different people: African American, Korean, Japanese, British, Spanish and many others. At first I was uncomfortable, and so was everyone else, since it was grade eight and most people were unknown to each other. As time passed, I became friends with many students in my grade; it became obvious to me that my main group of friends were from my elementary school or were from a Chinese culture. I guess it is more comfortable to be around people who share some understanding of your background. During lunch I notice the cafeteria has small groups of people at each table sharing something in common: ethnicity, sports, computer games, homework, or trouble making. The diversity is slight but it shows during lunch break or when we choose partners for any activity.
During my five years in high school I have been to many different parts of the Lower Mainland celebrating birthdays, doing projects, and having fun. I noticed the great variety of shops in
Living with my parents for eighteen years, I find them to be slightly traditional and because of their language barrier they tend to feel more comfortable with friends of Chinese or Vietnamese descent. I’ve noticed that parents who have come from a different country are more likely to remain in a community where they can communicate with others and less likely to expand and assimilate into other cultures. The reason for this may be because back home, their parents had their own opinion of people outside the country and how they behave. Therefore, when they came to
Diversity is not a bad thing since it distinguishes the many different cultures in
by Kamille Chavez Manoy

Kamille Chavez Manoy
by Peter Tian

Peter Tian
Many describe
I think the most visible evidence of a fissure in
Canadian immigration policy allows people from everywhere in the world to come to one place, creating a unifying effect. My family moved to
Multiculturalism hopes that everyone exercises tolerance and respect for other cultures, but underestimates the impact that historical backgrounds have upon different cultural groups. Hatred as a result of atrocities between cultures and countries, such as war crimes, are felt deeply and passed on generation by generation. For example, the 14-year Japanese invasion of
If multiculturalism failed in uniting the Anglophones and Francophones, how can we expect it to succeed in uniting other cultural groups, many of which have equally complicated history and unique customs? Without the near-impossible healing of historical wounds first, how can

2006 Finalists